Which Pop-Tart is the Top-Tart?: The most obscure Pop-Tarts flavors ranked worst to best

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.

Email This Story

10. Cinnamon Roll: I have never been a fan of cinnamon rolls, so it’s a good thing this tastes nothing like one. It tastes exactly like a Nutri-Grain Bar. This Pop-Tart has the worst aftertaste and I would not recommend it unless you enjoy eating things that are in no way appealing! Overall Rating: 1/10

9. Strawberry Cheesecake Drizzle: This Pop-Tart tastes like strawberry but with an overwhelming taste of icing. There is a hint of cheesecake, but I would much rather stick to the classic Strawberry flavor. If offered to eat this again I would decline. Overall Rating: 3/10

8. Chocolatey Salted Caramel: The “crust” of this Pop-Tart tastes like a cross between chocolate cake and cardboard. 10/10 recommend if you’re into that kind of thing. You can really taste the salt and caramel as you get towards the center of the toaster pastry, and it does taste a lot more cohesive and enjoyable when microwaved. Overall Rating:4/10

7. Vanilla Milkshake: This tastes exactly like a Little Debbie Zebra Cake. I find it too sweet to eat, and I would only recommend to a small child. It very much reminds me of a dessert, not a breakfast food. Overall Rating: 5/10

6. Chocolate Peanut Butter Gone Nutty: This is just a Nutter Butter cookie in Pop Tart form. It’s not bad at all, but it’s a bit too dense and heavy for my liking. You really need an acquired taste to enjoy this one. Overall Rating: 5/10

5. Strawberry Milkshake: I enjoyed this flavor because it was like strawberry but more bearable. It resembles the taste of strawberry yogurt, but it has a very strange textured filling. I would definitely eat this flavor again, but I would not spend my hard earned dollars on it. Overall Rating: 6/10

4. Hot Fudge Sundae: This Pop-Tart was by far the most appealing one to look at. It has a white frosting on a brown crust with chocolate drizzle and sprinkles! Although I think this tastes closer to a chocolate graham cracker with icing than a hot fudge sundae, I still enjoyed it! I recommend heating this in a microwave for the best flavor. Overall Rating: 8/10

3. Wildlicious Wild Berry: This one tastes like a mix of Blueberry and Raspberry Pop-Tart flavors. It’s very sweet with a bit of an artificial taste. Also, it’s vegan! Overall Rating: 8/10

2. Raspberry: This Pop-Tart is like no other. It’s a mix of blueberry and strawberry flavors but ten times better, and I found that it tasted like a homemade jam. It immediately replaced blueberry as my favorite fruit flavored Pop-Tart. If you like the classic blueberry or strawberry Pop-Tart flavors you are going to love this! It’s also vegan! Overall Rating: 9/10

1. TOP TART~ Chocolate Cookie Dough: No Pop-Tart compares to this one. The center tastes so much like cookie dough it’s insane, and it has just the right amount of sweetness to it! This is so good microwaved, I would eat this every day if I could. Overall Rating: 10/10